How to Promote on Reddit: Comments, Posts and What Works

What to write in a Reddit comment, when your product belongs in it, and how to post without getting removed.

Kalo YankulovKalo Yankulov10 min readUpdated 19 Nov 2026
What you'll needTools usedClaudeClaudeSensorhubSensorhubBeginner

How to Promote on Reddit: Comments, Posts and What Works

Marketing

10 min read

What to write in a Reddit comment, when your product belongs in it, and how to post without getting removed.

Kalo Yankulov

Written by Kalo Yankulov

Co-founder, Sensorhub

At Encharge, my previous startup, I posted a link to one of our best articles on Reddit. It got me 4 upvotes and a ban. Later, I republished the same content as a text post tailored to that subreddit, and it got 39 upvotes and 14 comments.

How come?

Nothing in the content changed between the two. I only turned a link into a text post for that subreddit. And that’s mostly how you promote on Reddit, folks.

Before you promote anything: be sure the product can take it. Reddit rewards products people recommend without being asked, and it picks weak ones apart. Like seriously, some Redditors feed on this. If people who compare you with the alternatives pick the alternative, seeing you more on Reddit won’t help. Fix the product first. The 7-question checklist in the overview tells you whether Reddit is the right channel for you.

How to promote on Reddit in four steps

  1. Read the rules. Then watch what gets removed anyway.

  2. Write a comment that helps with no brand mentions. For better or worse, most of your Reddit marketing is this.

  3. Decide whether the product belongs in it. Sometimes it does.

  4. Post, once you have a few comments under your belt. Write for one subreddit.

Reddit promotion starts in the comments

When you comment, you reach the people already reading the thread, and the people who find it on Google if it ranks. When you post, you start with no readers, and moderators are watching for self-promotion. Don’t be brave, start humble.

Comments are also where brands get talked about. In our data, 7 in 10 brand mentions on Reddit are in comments, not in the post. People rarely start a thread about a product. They ask what everyone uses, and the products come up in the answers, which is where you want to be.

So this is why this chapter has three steps on comments and one on posts.

Step 1: Read the rules, then watch what gets removed

Open the rules of each subreddit before you write a word. Many ban vendors outright, require a flair, or limit self-promotion to one weekly thread. Reddit itself leaves this to each community, which is why the same comment is fine in one subreddit and a ban in the next. Appendix B has the promotion rules for 66 subreddits, by buyer type.

The written rules are half of it. Sort the subreddit by new, look at what’s there, and come back a day later. What disappeared in between tells you what the moderators enforce. Yes, I know its tedious, but you have to test the waters first. No automation here.

In Chapter 6 I list the 45 things that get marketers removed, each with an example. Read it once before your first comment. This chapter is about what to write instead.

Step 2: Write a comment that helps (with no brand in it)

Ken Savage has the simplest test I know. Every comment his team writes has to pass it before it goes live: delete the brand name and ask if the comment is still useful. If it is, post it. If it isn’t, you wrote an ad.

Reddit users don't hate companies. They hate being sold to in a place they came to for honest answers.

Ken SavageKen SavageOn LinkedIn

What a useful comment has in it is one of the few things the Reddit people agree on:

  • Ross Simmonds looked at the comments AI answers lift from Reddit and found the same traits every time: a direct answer up front, specifics, some structure, first-hand experience and no pitch.

  • Krista Doyle wants lived experience with a mechanism and a number. “We struggled with this for about a year” does more than any summary of best practices.

  • Kamel Ben Yacoub, who runs an ads agency, wrote on Buffer’s blog that he tries to “focus on immediately helping the poster out instead of trying to sell your services”. He almost never adds a call to action. People who want to work with him click his profile, and that got him two clients in six months.

  • Pietro Montaldo teaches three parts in his Reddit Mastery Guide: show you understood the problem, give the advice with alternatives, and only then a soft mention, if it fits.

Here’s a comment that does all of it. A student on r/HVAC asked if the job market is as bad as it looks, and the owner of an HVAC company answered:

Reddit user
r/HVAC
u/Vegasology
Is the HVAC job market really this bad, or is this normal?
I'm currently attending HVAC school in Southern California, and something happened in class last week that has me seriously questioning the job market. […] He told us that after graduating last May, he submitted approximately 40 job applications and didn't receive a single interview.
u/kdilly16
•
Good example, real comment
I don't know what it's like from your shoes, but I own a company in a decent size market so I can offer that perspective. The 3 qualities that I look for when hiring technicians are: 1. Professionalism: not necessarily like “suit and tie” professional. However, you are in people's homes and you are the face of the company. […] 2. Communication: You are expected to communicate with customers. You'd be surprised how many candidates cannot communicate past one word responses during the interview process. 3. Actual knowledge of units: learn and truly understand superheat, subcool, the refrigerant cycle, etc.. […] If a candidate nails these three things, I make job offers every time.

He says who he is in the first line, because that’s why his answer is worth reading (credibility, duh). Then he gives three specific things, numbered. He never names his company, and he doesn’t need to. Anyone who wants to know more can click his name.

How long should a Reddit comment be?

Here the advice and the data don’t match. Montaldo suggests a “deep dive” of 300 to 500 words when you have real expertise. Our numbers say the comment that wins is short. In 21,455 threads, the typical top comment is 40 words long, and three out of four are under about 80.

That doesn’t mean short is more helpful. A short comment is easier to read to the end, and the ones that win usually carry one specific thing: an insight, a piece of advice, and quite often a joke. A long answer can be the most useful one in the thread and still sit in fourth place.

I’d follow the question. A simple question gets two or three sentences, and most questions on Reddit are simple. Go long when the person asked for a breakdown and you have the experience to fill it, the way the HVAC owner did. Never make a comment longer to look thorough.

Write it yourself

Once a reader thinks a comment came from AI, they stop reading. Doyle has a good ear for it. After a year in marketing subreddits she says the sentence “if you have this problem, then a tool like X can help” sets off her astroturfing alarm every time, whether it was astroturfing or not. Her fix is to sound like a person: conversational, curious, a bit funny.

And go back. In our data, 6 in 10 threads have a reply from the person who posted. They’re reading the answers, so if they ask you a follow-up and you never return, they see someone who dropped a comment and left.

You still don’t have to start from an empty box. Sensorhub’s reply assistant does the first pass.

How to see why a thread is worth a reply automatically in Sensorhub

You don't have to read a thread to find out if it's for you. Every thread in Signals has a score badge, green for the ones worth your time and red for the ones that aren't. Hover over it and Sensorhub tells you why it gave that score, in one sentence about this post and your business. If it got it wrong, rate the relevancy and the next threads are scored with that in mind.

Below the score, Insights says what the person is asking, and Post Preview shows the post with its comments, so you can see who has already answered.

The score badge of a Reddit thread in Sensorhub with its explanation, magnified: Top priority, 95%, the user is actively looking for marketing automation tools

How to get a first draft in your own voice in seconds in Sensorhub

Open the Actions tab on the thread, pick the voice of the account you'll post from and press Generate Comment. Sensorhub reads the thread and writes a draft that fits it, with the reasoning next to it. The one below says who the writer works for and what the product doesn't do, because that's how the voice is set up.

Treat it as a starting point. Change it until it sounds like you, then press Copy & open Reddit and post it yourself. Sensorhub never posts for you.

A reply drafted in Sensorhub for a Reddit thread, with Copy Reply and Copy and open Reddit buttons

Give the draft your own voice

A draft is only as good as the voice behind it, and this is the part I’d spend real time on. “Friendly founder, writes casually” gets you the same comment everyone else’s AI writes. A voice that sounds like you needs a lot of context: how you open, the words you never use, how you bring up your product, the two or three or 30 stories you always tell.

You don’t have to write that from memory. Claude can write it from what you’ve already written. Open Claude Code in your repo, so it can read your site copy and docs, and connect the tools where your writing lives through MCP: email, Slack, Notion, your LinkedIn posts. You can use a platform like Apify to scrape your whole LinkedIn post history, it will cost you less $5-10. Unless you are the Stephen King of LinkedIn, than in that case add a zero…or two.

Then ask for a voice file:

Open in Claude
Write a voice file for me and save it as voice.md. Read what I've actually written, in everything connected here: my sent emails, my Slack messages, my LinkedIn and Reddit posts, and the docs and site copy in this repo. Cover how I open, how long my sentences are, the words I use and the ones I never use, how I bring up my product, and two or three real stories I repeat. Quote my own sentences as examples. Don't describe a generic friendly founder. If you don't have enough of my writing to answer a point, say so and don't guess.
Calling Sensorhub

voice.md

One line. A founder who digs up data other people missed and says what it means. No hype, no hedging.

How I start. With the answer or the number. I name the source and give the figure.

Never. Em dashes. “Game-changer”. “Excited to share”. A closing “What do you think?”

The opening of my own voice file. The whole file is below.Connect the Sensorhub MCP

Mine took dozens of rounds, and I still update it almost every day as I find things that sound off. When I hate something about an AI piece, I ask Claude to remember it in the voice.

Here’s the whole file, for you to copy and change:

voice.md
# Voice: Kalo Yankulov, co-founder of Sensorhub

## The one-line version

Write like a founder who digs up data other people missed and then tells you what it actually means. No hype, no hedging, no performance.

## How posts start

Lead with a specific external thing (a report, a post, a tool launch, a data point) and add my angle on it. No warm-up, no throat-clearing, no "here's something interesting I found."

Real examples:

- "Another great B2B research on AI citations by Fan Out and Krista Doyle"
- "HubSpot (the founders of inbound) just launched an AEO product."
- "Ty Magnin from Animalz put out a warning shot on AEO spend."
- "Saw a few founders of AI content tools sharing Ryan Law / Ahrefs piece..."

The opener names the source. The next sentence is the angle or the key number. The reader never has to wait for the point.

## The core move

Take something trending, find what everyone's missing or misreading, say that. This is not "hot take for engagement." It's the analytical habit: read a thing, find the gap in the conversation, fill it.

- "I think they're missing the point (conveniently or otherwise)."
- "Here's what Ryan (Director of Content at Ahrefs) actually uses to produce that content..." (when others were citing the conclusion but ignoring the conditions)
- "Claude Code's source code got leaked yesterday. So I did what any SEO nerd would do..."

The move works because I actually dig. I read the original report. I go through the source code. I pull the actual numbers.

Two moves that build on this:

- Make a call on where things are going, labeled as a forecast: "My forecast: I expect AI visibility tools to show Reddit citations falling further as Reddit locks down."
- Admit your own interest when it's relevant: "Most are published by vendors with something to sell (me included)."

## Data use

Always cite who did the research and give the actual number. Never "studies show" or "data suggests."

Real examples:

- "They just published a study of 33,526 AI citations across ChatGPT Plus, Perplexity, and Google AI Overviews. 1,000 B2B queries, 52 platforms tracked."
- "SEMrush analyzed 248,000 of them: 80% had fewer than 20 upvotes, the median post was 900 days old, and 80 words long."
- "ChatGPT Plus cited zero YouTube links across 1,000 queries. Zero."

If the source is unavailable, don't write the claim. Flag it as unsourced instead.

## How Sensorhub gets mentioned

Never as the main pitch. Always as context, a natural next step, or an honest "this is why we built it."

Right:

- "The fastest way to run this diagnostic is to plug your domain and your top two competitors into Sensorhub." (after explaining the diagnostic)
- "This is one of the core problems I built Sensorhub around." (after describing the problem)
- "Sensorhub is great for analyzing competitors across publicly indexed social channels." (answering a specific question)

Wrong: leading with Sensorhub, making it the point of the post, using it as a hook.

Exceptions: launch and feature posts can be about Sensorhub, but the problem still comes first and the claims stay specific. Saying what you won't do is part of the brand: "This is exactly why we don't automate Reddit at Sensorhub."

## Personal anchors

I use the same real examples repeatedly because they're proven.

- The Encharge story: "At Encharge, I dropped a link post and got 4 upvotes plus a ban. I republished the same content as a native text post and got 39 upvotes, 14 comments, and real traffic."
- Fluent Frame: about two months, 3,159 visitors, 700 sign-ups, 0 bans, $0 ad spend.
- Sensorhub started as a simple Reddit monitoring tool, and 2.0 monitors every channel.

These aren't anecdotes. They're the evidence under the claims.

## By platform

- LinkedIn: longer, more structured. Numbered questions or bullet breakdowns are fine when the content calls for it. Ends with a question that's actually open, or a strong declarative.
- X: from two sentences to a full thread. Can be more casual. Short observations with a single lesson. Still data-backed when making a claim.
- Reddit: native text post, never a link drop. Lead with the insight, not the setup.

## Tone

Direct. Skeptical of hype, especially AEO hype, and I can say so even while running an AEO company. Willing to be conflicted in public ("This one's conflicting for me..."). Willing to be frustrated ("Spent 3 hours using the Zapier AI Agent..."). Returns to first principles when the market gets noisy.

Personal posts stay light and specific. Casual markers like :D, ;) and P.s. appear occasionally, never as decoration throughout a post.

Not: inspirational, thought-leadery, community-building, "excited to share," "proud to announce."

## What never appears

- Em dashes or double dashes
- "Here's the thing:"
- "Let's dive in" / "Let's unpack"
- "In today's landscape"
- "Game-changer" / "Transformative"
- "Excited to share" / "Proud to announce"
- Vague attribution: "research shows," "studies indicate," "experts agree"
- Rule-of-three groupings for rhetorical effect
- Closing with "What do you think?" as a lazy engagement prompt
- Throat-clearing before the point

## Closing style

Four acceptable endings:

1. A strong declarative that lands the point without summarizing: "Not as sexy. But that's what the source code says."
2. A genuine open question that invites disagreement or real input.
3. Just stopping. When the last real point has been made, stop.
4. On an offer post, a plain offer. Say exactly what they get, and don't use fake scarcity.

Never: a summary paragraph that restates what was already said, or a closer that's really a CTA in disguise.

## The signal test

Before any draft goes out: does it contain a real signal only I could find by digging into Sensorhub, Reddit, a specific report, or my own customer conversations? If yes, continue. If it's a recycled take from the timeline, don't publish it.
Swap in your own name, stories and banned words. The structure is the part worth keeping.

And, btw, this is my short-form voice. I have a long-form one, too.

A face split down the middle into two different halves

Paste yours into a voice under Brand → Response Voices and every draft in Sensorhub starts from it.

You can also do the whole thing in Claude. The Sensorhub MCP connects Claude to your Sensorhub project, so it can pull the threads worth a reply and draft an answer for each one. The draft gets better there, because Claude can add what only you have: voice.md, your pricing page, the docs in your repo, last week’s customer calls. A draft that knows your real numbers and your real stories is a lot harder to mistake for AI.

Step 3: Decide whether the product belongs in the comment

This is where people split.

Should you name your product in a Reddit comment?

NoLeave the product out
Krista Doyle

Zero links. Zero product mentions. Pure answer. Let your branded handle be the brand mention while you stay the helpful human.

Krista DoyleThe Warmups
YesName it, and say it's yours
Pietro Montaldo

We ended up building our own tool for this (I'm the founder), but honestly Loom is great if you just need basic screen recording.

Pietro MontaldoReddit Mastery Guide
Ken Savage

The mention becomes a natural part of a good answer, not the reason for it.

Ken Savage

Doyle wouldn’t name it at all. Her account carries the brand’s name, so every helpful comment is already a mention. (Chapter 2 covers when a brand account makes sense.) Montaldo and Savage name the product when it answers the question, and say whose it is. Romàn at Gojiberry goes furthest: his playbook allows product mentions in up to half of what an account writes.

My rule sits between them and depends on the thread. If someone asked for a tool, name yours. That’s what they asked for, and holding it back helps nobody. It’s all Tsvetan Karakanov did at Fluent Frame: five or six threads a day where someone was looking for what he built, which brought 700 sign-ups in about two months with no bans. Those are the threads that score 75% or more in Sensorhub (Chapter 3 shows how to get that list). If nobody asked, leave it out and let your profile do the work.

Does your product belong in this comment?
0 of 4 answered
Did the person ask for a tool, or is the thread already about your product?
Does this subreddit allow brands to be named?
Would the comment still help if you deleted the product name?
Does the comment say that you work there?
0 to 2 yesLeave the product out and just answer3 yesFix the one that's a no first4 yesName it
Answer all 4 to see where you land.

The tag on a thread tells you what kind of thread it is before you read it.

How to know what kind of thread it is at a glance in Sensorhub

Sensorhub uses AI to read each thread and tag it: Evaluating purchase, Help request, Competitor complaint, Pricing discussion, Brand complaint, Community question and a few more. Nobody on your team does this by hand. Hover over a tag and it says what it means and that AI added it. You can filter the list by tag, so the pricing threads or the complaints about one competitor are a click away.

The Community question tag on a Reddit thread in Sensorhub, with its explanation: added by AI, an open question asked to the community rather than a vendor

Here’s how I read the tags:

  • Evaluating purchase. They’re choosing now. Name your product, your role and one competitor.

  • Help request and Community question. Answer the problem and leave the product out.

  • Competitor complaint. Someone is unhappy with a competitor you track. Say what you’d pick for their case. Don’t bash the competitor.

  • Pricing discussion. Give real numbers, yours included.

  • Brand complaint. The thread is about your brand. Answer as the brand, the way the Veeam engineer does further down.

When you do name it, three things make the difference.

No link. Type the name. People who are interested will search for it. Fewer than 1 in 10 top comments on Reddit have a link, and a link is the first thing a moderator’s filter looks for. Some subreddits absolutely despise it and have auto-bots for it.

Say who you are and are in the same sentence. Here’s someone doing it in an r/kubernetes thread that asked for the best enterprise cluster management software:

A Reddit comment by eciton90 that opens with: I hate sitting on my hands but I work for Spectro Cloud so you'll think I am biased if I recommend Palette

He works for one of the vendors, says so before anything else, and then spends the comment on what to ask every vendor, his own included. Bill Widmer points to Nick Lafferty at Profound doing the same thing: honest about where he works, answering product questions in the open. That comment had 5 upvotes and several replies. It doesn’t sound like much, but Widmer is right that for a comment from a vendor it’s a good result.

People on Reddit mind being fooled a lot more than they mind being sold to. When HubSpot asked Reddit users what puts them off most when brands show up, 49.5% said fake organic posts. Obvious promotion got 20.4%. Denis Yurchak tried the fake way when he launched his eSIM app and wrote about it on X: it brought about 30 customers, he “of course got banned a lot”, and he doesn’t recommend it to anybody.

Shady marketing means you will be fighting with the platform, and it's an uphill battle. Much better is to write actual useful content, help people, and let Reddit help you in return.

Denis YurchakDenis YurchakFounder of eSIMPal and Yadaphone, on X

Mention the competitors. “We’re good for small teams, but if you have 500 people, go with X” is the comment people trust, because no ad would say it.

Sometimes the thread is about leaving you. In Chapter 3 I mentioned that a competitor’s unhappy customer is your best lead. This is the same thread from the other side, on r/sysadmin, titled “Looking for VEEAM alternatives”:

A Reddit comment by maxnor1 that opens with: Disclaimer, I'm a Veeam Systems Engineer

The price complaint is about his company, and he doesn’t argue with it. He says who he is, admits prices went up and offers a way to check the quote. That’s the most a brand can do in a thread like this, and it’s a lot better than being absent from it.

How to track negative mentions of your brand in Sensorhub

VisibilitySocial & Web Mentions

You can only answer a complaint you know about. Open Visibility → Social & Web Mentions, press Views and pick Negative brand mentions. Sensorhub reads the sentiment of every mention of your brand, so the complaints are already sorted out from the rest. Set Platform to Reddit to keep only the Reddit ones.

Each row opens the thread, so you can reply the way the Veeam engineer did: say who you are and deal with the complaint.

The Social & Web Mentions page in Sensorhub filtered to Reddit, Negative and mentions of the brand, listing nine Reddit posts and comments with a red Negative label on each

How much self-promotion is too much on Reddit?

The oldest of the Reddit self-promotion rules is nine helpful comments for every promotional one. It comes from a community guideline Reddit mentions, and it isn’t a sitewide rule. Gojiberry’s playbook says anything under half. With moderators as strict as they are now, I use three to one as the floor and five to one when there’s time.

A quick way to check yourself: count your last twenty comments. If more than five name the product, stop naming it for two weeks.

Step 4: Post, once the comments work

A post puts you in front of the whole subreddit, so write it for that subreddit. That means text and no link, which is the lesson of the Encharge story at the top. Our data says the same thing about links, and a few other things about titles:

Column chart: 19.6% of Reddit posts with a link in the text get no comments, against 4.6% of posts without a link. Source: Sensorhub.

Four things that change how a Reddit post does

From 512,758 Reddit posts, each at least a week old. The typical post is the one in the middle: half got more, half got less.

+55%

A question in the title gets more comments

17 against 11 on the typical post

+83%

A first-person title gets more upvotes

11 against 6 on the typical post, for titles with I, my, we or our

4x

A link makes a post more likely to get no comments at all

1 in 5 posts with a link, against 1 in 20 without

−36%

“I built” in the title gets fewer comments

9 against 14 on the typical post

Sensorhub data

A question gets answers, the first person gets upvotes, and “I built” reads as a launch. Also, you can skip the advice about the best day and hour to post.

Here’s a post that follows all of it. The owner of a simulation studio wrote on r/gamedev about what AI coding tools did to his team:

u/PuffThePed
r/gamedev • 23 Sep 2026
AI models have caught up with Unity dev. My insights as someone with 30 years of experience.
Context: I have 30 years of experience with software dev, 20 years with game dev tools, 10 years with Unity. I own a studio that develops simulators and training applications for industry. […] Here are my insights in no particular order: 1. Our dev speed has ~5x almost overnight 2. Quality has not gone down because we're all experienced devs and we're careful how we use AI […] 5. The market is dead. Nobody has money to spend. We're still working but leads have dropped off a cliff. […]

Look at the title: first person, with his experience in it. He says he owns a studio and never names it. The post is eleven numbered observations, some of them bad news about his own business. It got 2,572 upvotes and 1,295 comments, and everyone who read it now knows what his studio does.

Romàn’s Gojiberry playbook lists four formats that keep working, and I agree with the list:

Four kinds of Reddit post that keep working

What each one is and what you need before you write it. All four are text posts written for one subreddit, with no link.

Snoo telling a story by a small campfire
Nine parts useful, one part youA story
What you write
Something that happened to you and what you learned from it, told in the first person. The business gets one line, or none.
What you need first
A real win or a real failure. People can tell when the story was built around the product.
Snoo pointing at a small chart on an easel
Show the processA case study with numbers
What you write
What you did, step by step, and what came out of it, with the real numbers. The steps are the useful part.
What you need first
Numbers you're willing to show and to defend when the comments question them.
Snoo sitting behind a small microphone, listening
Only once they know youAn AMA
What you write
You say who you are and take questions for a few hours. Chapter 2 shows Grindr's CEO doing one from the brand account.
What you need first
A history in that subreddit, a yes from its moderators, and the afternoon free to answer.
Snoo weighing two boxes on a small scale
Read for yearsA comparison
What you write
An honest rundown of the options for one job, yours included, with who each one suits and who it doesn't.
What you need first
To be fair to the competitors. If yours wins every row, it gets called out as an ad.

Gojiberry credits posts like these for a real part of its growth. Prerona Basu says educational posts in SaaS subreddits took them from 100 to 250 customers. That’s their own account, so treat it as a direction.

Where I part ways with that playbook is reposting. It puts each post in ten or more subreddits. I’d write one post for one subreddit. The same post in many places at once is number 37 on the list of things that get accounts flagged, and it reads badly to anyone who’s in two of those communities.

A subreddit that filters your brand name is still worth your time. The agency MIKS suggests two things: keep answering there about the category without naming the brand, and use the neighbouring subreddits, where the same people read and the filters are softer, for the mention.

Can you promote in Reddit DMs?

Some growth advice treats Reddit DMs as an outbound channel. Gojiberry’s playbook has scripts for them, and Om Patel tells founders on X to message 10 to 15 people a day who complain about a competitor, which I wouldn’t do. Jonny Waite has the rule I’d follow: answer in public first, and message someone only when there’s already a conversation to continue or a support problem that needs their details. Reddit’s spam rules cover unsolicited mass messages, and people report them.

Reddit DMs are most useful when there's already a conversation worth continuing.

Jonny WaiteJonny WaiteRECHO, on LinkedIn

One short message to someone who thanked you in a thread is fine:

u/their_usernameReddit chatGood example

They replied “thanks, this helped” to your comment in the thread

Hey, glad the answer in the thread helped. If you get stuck moving the flows over, message me here and I'll walk you through it.
Appreciate it. Might take you up on that next week.
One message, to one person, after a conversation in public. No link and no offer.

This is the one that gets reported:

u/a_strangerReddit chatDon't send this

You have never talked to this person

Hi! Saw your post in r/marketing. We help teams like yours automate their email, and customers see results in the first week. Do you have 15 minutes this week? Here's my calendar: [link]
Unsolicited, templated and with a link. Reddit's spam rules cover exactly this.

Both are examples I wrote, not real messages. The difference is that the first person already talked to you and the message asks for nothing.

How Reddit spam farms work, and why I wouldn’t use one

There is a category of tools that promise to do your Reddit replies for you. Behind most of them is a spam farm, which is a pool of Reddit accounts that one operator controls and rents out to post on behalf of paying brands. In April 2024, 404 Media investigated one of them, ReplyGuy, and the setup it found is the same one most of these astroturf tools use. You enter your product name and a link, the tool suggests keywords, and a bot starts replying to matching threads with a comment that mentions your product. The replies didn’t come from you. ReplyGuy’s FAQ said at the time, “we send the replies from our pool of high quality Twitter and Reddit accounts.”

On its site today, ReplyGuy describes the process in five steps:

  • You choose keywords for your product.

  • The tool tracks mentions of those keywords across the web.

  • Its AI picks recent posts where your product could get a mention.

  • Its AI writes a reply that mentions your product.

  • The reply is sent, and the tool moves on to the next post.

The site now says you approve each reply, and that on Reddit it posts from your own account if you connect one and from theirs if you don’t. Its FAQ also warns that Reddit has a high ban rate, with accounts banned and replies removed far more often than on the other platforms it covers.

Spam farms also sell the accounts themselves. The same article covers sellers who offer old, high-karma accounts for “parasite SEO”, which means finding a thread that already ranks on Google and commenting under it, then buying upvotes to push the comment up.

A lot of these tools are also built in public. Their founders post the dashboards, the bot accounts and the replies on X, because that is where the build-in-public crowd finds its first customers. ReplyGuy’s founder posted screenshots of his bot accounts replying across Reddit. In January 2025 the founder of another startup, Astral, posted a demo on X of an AI agent logging in to Reddit and writing a promotional comment, and Gizmodo wrote it up after Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian replied with a crying GIF. Showing the method in public gives Reddit everything it needs to check those accounts, and it makes the company behind them an easy target for a cease and desist letter.

I wouldn’t use a spam farm, for three reasons.

  1. Reddit treats it as spam. A Reddit spokesperson told 404 Media that this kind of activity counts as spam or content manipulation and breaks the site’s rules. Most of the accounts ReplyGuy’s founder had shown off as examples were already banned when the article came out.

  2. The removal is automated too. Reddit’s transparency report for July to December 2023 says two-thirds of all takedowns were for spam, and about three-quarters of those removals happened automatically. A spam farm posting the same pitch across subreddits is exactly what that system is built to catch.

  3. The comments aren’t on your account. The comment sits on an account you can’t control, and when that account is banned the comment goes with it. Your product name stays in the moderators’ memory, and a subreddit that has seen it spammed can filter the brand out.

The useful part of these tools is finding the thread, and that is the part Sensorhub does. It reads each thread with AI instead of only matching keywords, and it never posts for you or connects to your Reddit account. Posting the reply stays with you, from your own account.

Common questions about promoting on Reddit

Can you promote your business on Reddit?

You can where the subreddit allows it. Reddit leaves self-promotion to each community, so plenty of them ban vendors, ask for a flair or keep promotion to one weekly thread. Read each subreddit's rules first, and see Reddit's self-promotion rules in Chapter 6 for what Reddit bans everywhere.

Can you promote on Reddit for free?

You can, because comments and text posts cost nothing but time, and they're where most Reddit promotion happens. Fluent Frame got 700 sign-ups in about two months from replies in threads where someone asked for what it built.

Should you put a link in a Reddit comment?

I wouldn't. Type the product's name and let people search for it. Fewer than 1 in 10 top comments on Reddit has a link, and a link is the first thing a moderator's filter looks for.

Should you say you work for the company?

Always, and in the same sentence as the product name. When HubSpot asked Reddit users what puts them off most when brands show up, 49.5% said fake organic posts and 20.4% said obvious promotion. People mind being fooled a lot more than they mind being sold to.

Can you post the same thing in several subreddits?

I'd write one post for one subreddit. The same post in many places at once gets accounts flagged, and it reads badly to anyone who is in two of those communities.

Do this this week

Chapter 4 checklist
0 of 8 done
1Before you write30 minutes
2CommentsThe rest of the week
Signals in Sensorhub filtered to Reddit threads scoring 75% and above
3One postAn hour
Your ticks are saved in this browser, so you can come back to it.

Social listening and AI visibility platform for marketers

Grow your presence across AI search, social, and the web

Grow your presence across AI search, social, and the web

Grow your presence across AI search, social, and the web

Off-site visibility insights, every month

© 2026 Iterato Ltd. All rights reserved.

Off-site visibility insights, every month

© 2026 Iterato Ltd. All rights reserved.

Off-site visibility insights, every month

© 2026 Iterato Ltd. All rights reserved.