Reddit Lead Generation: Finding High-Intent Threads
How to find the Reddit threads where someone is asking for what you sell, and decide which ones deserve a reply.

Reddit Lead Generation: Finding High-Intent Threads
Marketing
10 min read
How to find the Reddit threads where someone is asking for what you sell, and decide which ones deserve a reply.

Written by Kalo Yankulov
Co-founder, Sensorhub

A buyer asks a subreddit which tool to use, for exactly what you sell. Over the next two days the thread fills up with replies, and three of your competitors are in it. You find it two weeks later through Google.
That’s how Reddit lead generation goes for most companies: late, and by accident.
A warning before you start: Reddit is not LinkedIn Sales Navigator. We see this belief from a lot of people who don’t use Reddit. No tool, ours included, turns Reddit into a list of leads you can export and email. A lead on Reddit is a conversation you can join, and somebody still has to write the reply. If your buyers don’t ask for recommendations there, no routine fixes that. The 7-question checklist in the overview is the quickest way to find out.
Reddit lead generation in three steps
Know what a good thread looks like. So you stop reading the other 996.
Decide between fresh and old. They get you different things.
Run a routine. One you’ll keep.
What a Reddit lead looks like
It’s a person asking strangers what to buy. Here’s one from r/Frugal:

Best online stores for prescription glasses?I'm looking to buy prescription glasses online (around −5.5 SPH, mild astigmatism). Some online retailers offer complete glasses, including frames and 1.74 lenses, for around $100, compared with ~$300 at a local optical store after insurance. Which online retailers have you had good experiences with regarding prescription accuracy, lens quality, and optical alignment? I'm particularly interested in stores offering at least a 30-day return policy and preferably a one-year warranty. Any recommendations or experiences with Zenni, EyeBuyDirect, GlassesUSA, or others?
Look at what’s in it. There’s a specific need, a budget, a return policy they care about, and the names of three stores they’re already comparing. Under it are 79 comments from people weighing in. If you sold glasses online, this is the thread you’d want to be in.
Threads like this are rare. In our data, about 4 in every 1,000 posts in the subreddits a company follows are a lead. The typical one has 9 comments, against 5 for all posts, and 43% have a question mark in the title. So you’re looking for a question with a discussion under it, in a pile of news, jokes and stories. Appendix B maps the subreddits where those questions show up, by kind of buyer.
Step 1: Know what a good thread looks like
Ross Simmonds scores each thread on four things: intent (the asker is close to a decision), reach (the thread will be seen and indexed), fit (you can give the best answer) and freshness. He goes after the questions that come back every month, like best X for Y, X vs Z and is X worth it, because those threads keep getting read long after they’re written.
I agree with all four. The hard part is that you can’t search for them.
Liran Blumenberg tried. He set up alerts for “looking for” and “anyone recommend” and counted what came back for a month.
Only 2.8% of keyword-alert matches were someone asking to buy
One month of alerts for the phrases “looking for” and “anyone recommend” on Reddit, X, LinkedIn, Nextdoor and Facebook groups: 62,296 posts matched. Counted by Liran Blumenberg; the post counts below are worked out from his 2.8%.
“Looking for a plumber” turned out to be a job ad six times out of six. His fix was to name the service in the phrase, which helps, and still leaves you reading a lot of posts that aren’t buyers.
I ran into the same thing while looking for examples for this chapter. I searched post titles for best … for …?. The glasses thread above came back. So did this one:

Is Dougie Cochrane legitimately the best player in this draft or is he being used for the compensation pick?It shocks me that a player who was mostly injured and only played 4 games this season and was frankly bad in all of them, to then skip the draft combine is the consensus number one. […]
It has the same words and the same 79 comments, and it’s about a football draft. (Sorry, keyword alerts.) It works the other way too: a post can describe your product exactly and use none of your keywords.
So what you need is something that reads the whole post. Matching words isn’t enough.
How Sensorhub finds them
This is the problem we built Sensorhub for.
You give it your website. From that it works out what you sell, who buys it and who you compete with, and it keeps that picture of your business as the context for everything it analyzes. You don’t write a list of keywords.
Then it goes through the posts in your communities and gives each one a score from 0 to 100%. The score answers two questions:
Intent. Is this person looking for a solution?
Relevancy. Is it a problem your business solves?
A post that mentions your category ten times and is only a rant scores low. However, a post that describes exactly what you sell scores high, even if it never mentions your exact match "keywords". That’s the difference between reading a post's context with AI and simply matching words in it.
Sensorhub also tells you what kind of post each one is. A brand mention names you, and a competitor mention names a competitor you track (I know, I know… I'm captain obvious). Both are worth watching. But for leads, the kind that matters is the intent signal: a conversation where someone has the problem you solve and is asking what to do about it. That’s where your potential leads are. And, yes, one post can be both a competitor/brand mention and an intent signal – we have filters in the app that allow you to narrow to a specific type or a combination.
Here’s how it looks in practice:
You don't search for anything. Sensorhub keeps finding and scoring threads in the background, so the list is already there when you open it. Open Signals, tick the 85%+ and 75–85% score filters and pick Reddit under Platform. 85% and above is top priority. I'd start at 75%, because below that line threads are about your field but nobody in them is asking for a product.
To see only potential leads, untick everything under Mentions except Intent signal.

One of the best leads is someone leaving a competitor
There’s one kind of thread I’d put ahead of all the others: someone asking for an alternative to a product they already know:

Are there alternatives to the jet boil?We basically just need something small and compact that boils water. It doesn't need to cook anything or do literally anything else but boil water, it doesn't even need to be particularly durable. And $100 is a bit steep for us at the moment to invest in this, so wondering about any alternatives to the jetboil. Thanks!
They’ve named the product, said what they need it for and told you what’s wrong with it: the price. Nobody has to explain the category to them, they are already problem and solution aware. And 128 people answered, so this thread is where the next person searching jetboil alternatives ends up.
If you Google, you find these with [competitor] alternatives and [competitor] vs. But in Sensorhub we find them for you automatically.
In your reply, say what you’d pick for their case and why, and say who you work for. Don't be the bullie that bashes the competitor.
Add each competitor to your Watchlist once. From then on Sensorhub tracks every post that names it, and you never run a search. Open Signals, keep only Competitor only ticked under Mentions and Negative under Sentiment. What's left is people who are unhappy with a competitor, in threads where you aren't mentioned yet.

Check a thread before you reply
Before you write anything, run the thread through these four questions. Of course, once you get used to them, you'll spot Reddit threads without checking this widget every time.
Step 2: Fresh or old? Decide by what you want
This is where the people I trust for Reddit advice contradict each other, and one of them contradicts himself (difficult times, I know).
Should you reply to fresh threads or old ones?

Hour 1-2: Get in during this window. Early upvotes push your comment to the top. 6+ hours: only comment if you have something truly unique.

We showed up consistently: 4 founder-voiced posts a month, 30 to 40 comments, and replies to rising threads within 24 hours.

They found old Reddit threads ranking on Google for “Best [Category] Tools.” Posted genuine comments about their product.

“Best X for Y.” “X vs Z.” “Is X worth it.” Those evergreen threads get indexed and cited for years.
Pietro Montaldo is on both sides, and he’s right both times, because the two sides answer different questions.
A fresh thread gets you in front of the person who asked. They’re still reading replies, and the thread is still climbing. Our own numbers back the rush: in 21,455 threads, 48% of top comments were written within an hour of the post.

Don’t read that as a race you have to win every time. Nobody catches every thread in its first hour. Getting there the same day is a realistic target, and the person who asked is very likely still reading.
An old thread gets you everyone who searches that question later. One in four leads in our data is on a post more than a month old, and one in ten is on a post more than a year old. Those are also the threads AI answers pull from.
Put in other words: Marketers reply to threads that are about a day old, and AI cites threads that are more than a year old.
The typical Reddit thread AI cites is 16 months old
How old a Reddit thread is when a marketer replies to it, and when ChatGPT or Google AI Overviews cite it. Typical means the middle value: half are older, half are newer. Sensorhub data.
Chapter 5 covers what to do about that.
There’s one way to get the old ones wrong, however. Reviving a two-year-old thread only to drop your brand name is not cool, and moderators remove it. Reply to an old thread when your answer adds something the thread doesn’t have yet. And apologize for bringing it back. “Sorry for resurrecting this," for instance.
Here’s what marketers do in practice:
The typical thread our users save to reply to scores 83%, is a little over a day old and already has 9 comments. So they go for fresh threads, but not empty ones.
My take: do both, and keep them in separate lists, because you work them differently. The fresh list is a daily job, and the old list is one good answer a week.
You set this up once. Keep the filters from the step above, open the sort menu at the top of the list and pick Newest first. Then save it from the view menu. That's your list for leads, and new threads land in it on their own.

For the second view, pick Most engagement in the same menu and save that one too. Those are the threads worth a lasting answer.

You don’t have to guess which thread is which. When a thread is old, the signal says so, and reminds you that established threads rank well in search.
And, BTW, you can save these views for easy access using our View feature.
Step 3: Run a routine, not a campaign
Reddit leads come from showing up every week for months, so pick a routine you can keep. The account you reply from has to be ready first: Chapter 2 covers how to warm it up. Here are four ways to do it.
Four ways to run a Reddit lead generation routine
What each routine is and what it takes to keep it going. The first needs no tool. The other three are what people who get customers from Reddit do.

- What you do
- Search Google for site:reddit.com plus your category question, limited to the past 24 hours, and sort each of your subreddits by new every morning.
- What it takes
- A lot of reading. You see every post, and about 4 in 1,000 are leads.

- What you do
- Tsvetan Karakanov at Fluent Frame opened his list of high-intent threads each day, picked five or six and wrote every reply by hand.
- What it takes
- A short slot every working day, and a list that is already sorted for you.

- What you do
- Pietro Montaldo pulls the top and the newest posts from each of his communities once a week, picks three per community, drafts replies, then edits and posts them himself.
- What it takes
- A sheet of your communities and their rules, checked again every three months.

- What you do
- Ken Savage's team maps the questions buyers search for, finds the subreddits where those questions already rank on Google, then writes 4 founder posts and 30 to 40 comments a month.
- What it takes
- A person or an agency on it most of the week, and replies to rising threads within 24 hours.
Montaldo says his weekly run gets him two or more customers a month. Savage reports one client going from 0.8% to 23.6% of trials from Reddit in six months. Both numbers are self-reported, and Savage’s client isn’t named, so take them as a direction.
The by-hand version is a Google search for site:reddit.com "best [your category]" with the time filter on the past 24 hours. It costs nothing, and it stops working when you add a second product or a second person.
Take the weekend off. We see 35% fewer leads on a Saturday than on a Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday. People ask for tools when they hit the problem, and that’s at work.
In Sensorhub the routine is the two views from Step 2. Star a thread you want to come back to, and set its status to To do, In progress or Done once you’ve handled it, so you and your team can see what’s been handled. Signals covers 11 social and community platforms, so the same routine catches the LinkedIn and X versions of the question.
If you’d rather not open another tab, connect the Sensorhub MCP to Claude and ask for the list:
Sensorhub has more than 15 Reddit threads at 85% or higher for Sensorhub since 11 November. The five best:
Reply first: the r/socialmedia thread. The person is losing a tool they depend on, names the platforms they need covered and asks what to use, so they have a reason to decide soon.
One thing to watch: the first thread was also posted word for word in r/DigitalMarketingHack. Answer it once.
Either way, Sensorhub doesn’t post for you. We never automate posting, and that’s on purpose.
What Reddit lead gen looked like for Fluent Frame
Tsvetan had lost several Reddit accounts to automated posting before he tried this. He started again with a new domain, no audience and no ad budget, and ran the daily routine: five or six threads a day, each reply written by hand.
I can see that somebody on Reddit has posted that he is searching for a tool that can help with turning their changelog into an explainer video, for example, and I can go straight to them and say, hey, we have it, check it out.
Tsvetan KarakanovFounder, Fluent FrameBetween 17 February and 22 April 2026, Fluent Frame got 3,159 visitors and 700 sign-ups, with $0 ad spend and no bans. Sensorhub found the threads, and Tsvetan wrote the comments.
Chapter 4 covers what to write in those comments.
Common questions about Reddit lead generation
Is Reddit good for B2B lead generation?
It is when your buyers ask for recommendations there, and it isn't a list of leads you can export. In our data about 4 in every 1,000 posts in the subreddits a company follows are a lead, so you have to find those few posts and write each a useful reply. Fluent Frame got 700 sign-ups in about two months that way, with no ad spend.
How do you find leads on Reddit?
Look for people asking strangers what to buy: best X for Y, X vs Z, and alternatives to a product they already use. By hand, search Google for site:reddit.com plus your category question, limited to the past 24 hours. Keyword alerts catch too much, because in one month-long test only 2.8% of the matches were someone asking to buy.
Can you automate Reddit lead generation?
You can automate finding the threads, and you shouldn't automate the replies. Fluent Frame lost several accounts to automated posting before it switched to replies written by hand. Sensorhub finds and scores the threads, and it never posts for you.
Should you reply to new Reddit threads or old ones?
Do both, because they get you different things. A new thread gets you the person who asked, and 48% of top comments are written within an hour of the post. An old thread that ranks gets you everyone who searches the question later, and one in four leads in our data is on a post more than a month old.
How long does Reddit lead generation take?
Plan in months. Leads come from showing up every week, and the account has to be warmed up before it can mention a product. Pietro Montaldo says his weekly routine brings him two or more customers a month, which is his own number.
Do this this week




