Why Reddit removed your post: 45 things that get marketers removed or banned

What gets a post or comment removed on Reddit, why each mistake backfires, and what to write instead.

Kalo YankulovKalo Yankulov15 min readUpdated 12 Nov 2026
What's inside45 mistakes with real examplesReddit's rules and Sensorhub data

Why Reddit removed your post: 45 things that get marketers removed or banned

Marketing

15 min read

What gets a post or comment removed on Reddit, why each mistake backfires, and what to write instead.

Kalo Yankulov

Written by Kalo Yankulov

Co-founder, Sensorhub

You wrote the post, pressed submit and went to make coffee. When you came back it was gone, and in its place was a grey line: “Sorry, this post was removed by Reddit’s filters.” Or a note from a moderator. Or nothing at all, the doom of crickets.

In B2B subreddits, marketers cause most of this themselves. One r/marketing moderator says about 80% of the posts there have to be removed as spam, and about the same share of comments.

This page lists the 45 things that get a post or comment removed, why each one backfires, and what to write instead. Every example is a real post or comment from our data. At the end you can test your own draft, with a checker or with a prompt.

A warning before the list. Nobody outside Reddit knows the exact triggers, me included. What follows comes from Reddit’s help pages, from what moderators have written, and from what we’ve seen happen to accounts. The same post can be fine in one subreddit and get you banned in the next.

Free download

Get the 45 rules as an .md file for Claude or ChatGPT

The Reddit Rulebook checks a draft the way this page does, and goes further than the checker.

Checks the subreddit's own rules first
Names the rule and quotes the line that breaks it
Rewrites the draft so it would pass
Works inClaudeChatGPT

We'll email you the .md file.

For Claude and ChatGPT
The Reddit Rulebook
45 mistakes that get marketers removed or banned, and the fix for each
Sensorhub

Why was my Reddit post removed?

Three different things remove posts on Reddit.

  1. “Removed by Reddit’s filters” means Reddit’s own automated system took it down. Reddit’s help page says its spam filter can stop posts from brand new accounts with little karma, and suggests commenting in that community first to earn some. The filter gets it wrong sometimes. If you think it did, send the subreddit’s moderators one short message and ask them to approve the post.

  2. “Removed by the moderators” means the subreddit did it: a person, or the script they run.

  3. No message, and the post is simply not showing up for anyone else? That may be a shadowban. I give the test for it in Chapter 7. This, also, often happens when you are posting in a subreddit that you haven’t joined.

Removals are rarer than they feel. Reddit’s transparency report says 2.66% of everything created between July and December 2024 was removed, 1.42% by moderators and 1.24% by Reddit’s admins. New accounts are the exception. Reddit’s CEO told moderators that 30% of posts from new accounts are removed.

Many removals are silent. In a 2019 study of 907 Reddit users, 41.8% had not noticed their post was gone until the researchers told them. Open your post in a private window before you assume it is live.

Removed by a moderator or by AutoModerator

AutoModerator is a script that each subreddit’s moderators write for themselves. It checks every post and comment against their conditions, such as how old the account is, how much karma it has, whether the text has a link, and which words it uses.

Moderators can also switch on two settings from Reddit.

The Reputation filter holds content from accounts that look like spammers or have no history yet.

The Reputation filter in a subreddit's moderator settings, with moderate and high filtering

Crowd Control holds posts and comments from people who aren’t trusted members of that community yet, until a moderator approves them.

Both lean on the Contributor Quality Score, a five-level rating Reddit gives every account based on its past behavior and whether the email is verified.

Most removals are done by a script. In the second half of 2025, 68.6% of moderator removals were made by AutoModerator or a moderation app, DocumentaryTube reports from Reddit’s transparency report. Being reported is rarely what does it: in the same period only 6.9% of user reports led to a removal.

A quick way to tell them apart: a post that disappears within seconds was caught by a filter. One that disappears hours later, with a note, was removed by a person.

The four things that can happen

Any mistake in the list below can end in one of four ways. Which one depends on the subreddit and on the moderator.

Label

What it means

Who does it

Ignored

Reddit downvotes, no replies, or a reply saying “this is an ad”

Other users

Removed

The post or comment is taken down

Reddit’s filters, AutoModerator or a moderator

Subreddit ban

You can’t post in that community again

Moderators

Reddit ban

The account is banned everywhere. Reddit also calls this a suspension. Moderators can ban a brand name too. One subreddit’s moderators published a list of more than 200 companies whose names are removed there automatically (see below).

Reddit’s admins

The examples below are real posts and comments. The number on each one is its score, which is upvotes minus downvotes. A score of -7 means seven more people downvoted it than upvoted it.

Reddit’s self-promotion rules

Reddit itself has no rule against promoting your business. Its spam page says promotional content is not spam by default, and that each community decides how much of it to allow. Some allow none.

The Reddit 9:1 rule, also called the 90/10 rule, comes from the same page: some communities use a guideline that no more than 10% of what you post should be your own. It isn’t one of the sitewide Reddit rules, and older advice still points to reddiquette, Reddit’s informal etiquette page. In this guide, I use a looser ratio: three to five helpful comments for each one that mentions the business.

What Reddit does ban everywhere is spam, meaning repeated or unsolicited actions that hurt users or communities, and manipulation, meaning fake votes and fake accounts. Most of the list below is one or the other.

Below, I will show you specific examples of bad Reddit practices and what you can do instead. Keep in mind: Reddit is subjective, and it’s normal to get banned; sometimes there is a good reason, and sometimes there isn’t. Don’t take it to heart, and keep learning.

Posts that read as ads

1. The pitch as a post

Reddit user
r/PromptEngineering • 28 Dec 2025
u/second_coffee
Real post
Releasing the most advanced meta system prompt for prompt engineering that took me 2 months to make
After 2 months of work, I finally have come down to a system prompt for my tool [product] [link to the Chrome Web Store] [product] is a *free* chrome extension that works with any AI that can create simple prompts or advanced JSON instructions that deliver mind blowing results. Next week, you will be able to store and organize prompts into folders too! … Today, I am releasing part of the mega prompt for [product]. … its current state beats the market no brainer... especially since its one of the only free tools out there. … [the prompt itself, about 38,000 characters] … So, please let me know what you think!!
020

Why it backfires: The post gives the subreddit nothing to talk about except your product. Moderators treat that as an ad, whatever the product is.

Write this instead: write about the problem and how you solved it, with numbers. In the example below the product is named once, in the third paragraph, and the one link comes near the end.

u/Unhappy_Dig_6276
r/gis • 23 Jan 2026
Better example, real post
I got tired of not knowing what city/country I was flying over, so I built my first app to solve it. (100% offline GPS)
Hey everyone, I wanted to share something I've been working on. Like many of you, I've spent countless hours on flights staring out the window wondering, "What city or country is that?" or "Where actually are we?" … So, I decided to build [product], my very first app. … If you're a frequent traveler, hiker, or just a geo-nerd like me, I'd love for you to check it out. Download it here: [link to the App Store page] Thank you so much for your support and feedback.
u/realtrotor
u/realtrotor • 23 Jan 2026
I had this exact idea about ten year ago! Glad you did that. Would be nice to know what city you are looking/passing and where it appears (on which side of the plane)

2. The link with nothing around it

A post or comment that is little more than a link to your site.

Reddit user
r/userexperience
u/Chronic-amazement
Great e-commerce examples
Reddit user
u/support_stack_ai •
Real comment
[link to their own site] I think this design I built is creative. It's different.. the client loves it and that's all that matters.
-7

Why it backfires: A link asks people to leave the thread before they know why they should. Most don’t, and the post gets no replies.

Write this instead: put the whole thing in the post. 1 in 5 posts with a link gets no comments, against 1 in 20 without one. A bare link works only when the thread asked for links, as in the second example.

Reddit user
r/ClaudeAI
u/mullemeeldib
Show me Claude Code projects that DON'T look vibecoded
since everybody here is asking which tools, skills or MCPs make UI look less "AI-generated". Could you guys actually provide me examples of apps/websites that dont look like that then?...
u/FraffoD
•
Better example, real comment
I made a 3d fighter game with Italian politicians in it: [link]
u/Overall_Purchase_467
u/Overall_Purchase_467 • 4 Nov 2026
damn ive never played a web game that felt so optimised on the phone. Amazing

3. The launch post in a community you’ve never written in

This one was removed even from a subreddit made for showing projects.

Reddit user
r/SideProject • 1 Sep 2026
u/plain_bagel_99
Real post, removed
I built a guard dog for AI Coding Agents: Every tool call gets allow/autheticate/block before it runs. LIVE ON PRODUCT HUNT TODAY
14

Why it backfires: You are asking for attention from people who have never seen you help anyone there.

Do this instead: write there for a couple of weeks first, then use the subreddit’s own promo thread if it has one. Don’t push the launch in the title. One line at the end of the post is enough. In the example below the links sit at the bottom, after the explanation, and the post says who it is not for.

u/matijaz
r/selfhosted • 7 Jan 2026
Better example, real post
I built a SIEM you can deploy with one command — Falco + Loki + Grafana with MITRE ATT&CK dashboards
I've spent 25 years in infrastructure, now in a SecOps role. The pattern I keep seeing: small teams have no visibility into what's happening on their systems. … So I built [product] — a complete security monitoring stack you can deploy with make install. … Who it's NOT for: Large enterprises with dedicated SOCs — you probably need commercial scale. Landing page with screenshots: [link] GitHub: [link] Would love feedback — especially on detection gaps. What rules would you add? What's missing?
u/Spare-Ad-1429
u/Spare-Ad-1429 • 7 Jan 2026
Interesting. For the uninitiated: What differentiates this from Wazuh?

“I built” posts get 9 comments against 14 for other posts.

4. Sales copy and bait titles

u/example
r/SaaS • made up
Made-up example
Tired of losing customers? Our platform fixes retention in a week
Grab a slot on my calendar.

Why it backfires: Reddit reads like a conversation, so ad copy stands out in the first line. People stop reading at that line.

Write this instead: a plain title that says what is inside. Titles written in the first person get 11 upvotes against 6.

5. The founder story with a plug inside

Reddit user
r/artificial • 26 Oct 2026
u/plain_bagel_99
Real post
How I Built A $20K/Month Web Design Business Using AI
For years I was building WordPress websites and trying to figure out how people were scaling web design agencies to serious money. I could build good websites, but getting clients consistently was a completely different story... Finding clients changed too. I started using [product] to find businesses with existing websites, analyze thousands of them and turn issues with design, SEO, speed and mobile optimization into personalized outreach emails. I could run multiple campaigns at once instead of spending my entire day looking for prospects...
06
u/riscie
u/riscie • 26 Oct 2026
This is an ad.

Why it backfires: Once readers spot the product, they reread the whole story as an ad, and that is what the replies are about.

Write this instead: tell the story with the real numbers. If you link, do it once, at the end, as context. The example below does exactly that in its last line.

u/felixheikka
r/SaaS • 16 Jan 2026
Better example, real post
The lessons I learned scaling my app from $0 to $30k/mo in 1 year
• 80%+ of people prefer Google sign in • Removing all branding/formatting from emails and sending them from a real name increases open rate … • Even when things are going well you'll have moments when you doubt everything, just have to shut that voice out and keep going For context, my app [link to the app's site] guides users through researching and planning their product.
u/CarelessEntrepreneur
u/CarelessEntrepreneur • 16 Jan 2026
A post written by a human? In this economy?! Awesome!

Fake accounts and astroturfing

Reddit astroturfing means making promotion look like it came from ordinary users. It is the fastest way to lose a subreddit, because people check your profile.

6. The fake question

Asking a question so you can answer it with your own product. We found no clean case in our data, but this reply shows how well Reddit knows the move.

Reddit user
r/ExperiencedDevs
u/Mr_Willkins
Too much slop
u/trailing_zero_count
•
A reply that names the move
Lot of AI slop, lot of thinly veiled ads ("how do you solve X problem", when the poster's SaaS claims to solve X problem)
352

Why it backfires: People open your profile. One look at your history shows whose product it is, and the thread turns on you.

Write this instead: answer someone else’s real question and say the product is yours.

7. “Not affiliated”, from the founder

Why it backfires: It is a lie that takes one click to check, and it costs more trust than the pitch would have.

Write this instead: “I work on [Product], so I’m biased.” Saying who you are doesn’t make a pitch welcome, but hiding it makes everything worse.

8. The rigged comparison

The “honest comparison” in which your own tool happens to win every row.

Why it backfires: A comparison where one tool wins every row tells readers who wrote it. Users of the other tools turn up to correct you.

Write this instead: say where the competitor is better. People trust the rest more.

9. The fake testimonial

A glowing “customer” story posted from an account opened that week.

Why it backfires: Account age is public. Praise from an account opened that week reads as the company talking to itself.

Do this instead: ask a real customer to answer in their own words, or don’t post it.

10. “Asking for a friend”

Reddit user
r/musictheory • 11 Nov 2026
u/second_coffee
Real post
What's Wrong with Music Theory
My friend wrote an interesting article about the shortcomings of teaching music theory: [three sentences quoted from the article] [link to the article, on a music-learning app's own site]
053
u/Dr_Fuzzles
u/Dr_Fuzzles • 11 Nov 2026
Yeah, this is an ad poorly disguised as a critique of music theory. It's literally a guy reinventing the wheel.

Why it backfires: Nobody believes in the friend, and you lose the chance to answer questions as the person who made the thing.

Do this instead: ask in your own name.

Reddit user
r/ClaudeAI
u/mullemeeldib
Show me Claude Code projects that DON'T look vibecoded
since everybody here is asking which tools, skills or MCPs make UI look less "AI-generated". Could you guys actually provide me examples of apps/websites that dont look like that then?...
u/Playeggball
•
Better example, real comment
I don't *think* my project looks vibe coded but I'd appreciate any insight from the community. Anything that does stand out as clearly AI-style generation I'd love to know. Thanks! [link]

11. A second account that agrees with you

A second account that asks the question, answers it or says “can confirm”.

Why it backfires: Reddit treats accounts that vote or reply together as manipulation, and it can act on all of them at once.

Do this instead: use one account in a thread. Reddit lets you own several accounts, but using them to vote on the same posts is vote manipulation.

12. Upvotes from the team

Dropping the link in the team Slack so everyone upvotes it.

Why it backfires: Votes that arrive together from colleagues are exactly the pattern Reddit looks for.

Do this instead: don’t ask anyone to upvote it. Reddit revokes nearly 2 million fake votes a day, Krista Doyle reports.

13. A new account after a ban

Opening a new account to get back into a subreddit that banned you.

Why it backfires: It puts the new account at risk, and any other account you run along with it.

Do this instead: appeal from the banned account. Reddit calls the new account ban evasion.

So far this has been about posting in other people’s subreddits. The same rules apply in a subreddit you own, and there Reddit can remove the whole community instead of one post. OtterlyAI ran a 60-day test with bots, self-added upvotes and identical scheduled posts in four subreddits of their own, and Reddit deleted all four.

Comments that sell

14. The product drop under someone’s problem

Reddit user
r/smallbusiness
u/Zestyclose_Ship6486
What part of running a small product business do you wish you had systemized earlier?
Reddit user
u/window_seat_7 •
Real comment
Hello there. You might want to check out our customer support AI automation tool, [link]. This solves your problem on repetitive customer questions by letting your CS AI solve the minor issues before escalating the big ones. Try the Sandbox first, no need for signup to experience the flow.
-6

Why it backfires: The person asked for help and got a product page. It reads as if you never read the post.

Write this instead: answer the problem first, in two or three sentences.

Reddit user
r/b2bmarketing
u/Background-Scar-7096
What's the most effective way to get B2B leads in 2025? Is buying valid leads still worth it?
u/erickrealz
•
Better example, real comment
I work at an outreach company and buying leads is mostly a waste of money - the good prospects are already being hit by 20 other vendors. Cold outreach still works but you need way better targeting and personalization than before. Generic "we help companies grow" emails get deleted immediately. LinkedIn prospecting is solid if you actually research prospects first. Find people posting about specific problems you solve, then reach out with relevant insights...

The typical top comment is 40 words, and fewer than 1 in 10 has a link.

When it’s fine: if someone is directly asking for a tool like yours, mention it. That is the answer to their question. Fluent Frame does exactly this. The founder only replies in threads where a person is looking for what he built. It brought 700 sign-ups from Reddit in two months, with no bans.

15. Answering “how?” with “use our tool”

Why it backfires: It skips the answer. The reader still doesn’t know how, and now doubts that you do.

Write this instead: explain how to do it by hand. Mention the tool as one way to do it faster.

16. The feature list

A wall of features in reply to a one-line question.

Why it backfires: The answer to their question gets lost among features nobody asked about.

Write this instead: the one feature that fits what they asked.

17. The same comment pasted into many threads

This comment sits under 21 threads in 11 subreddits, most of them months or years old. It was posted by a customer chasing a referral bonus, not by the company.

Reddit user
r/webdev and 10 other subreddits
u/anatolhiman
Lightweight alternative to Google Analytics?
One of the 21 threads it was pasted under.
Reddit user
u/second_coffee •
Real comment
GA4 is unusable. UA was great for me but GA4 ruined everything. The reporting is inaccurate and delayed. I switched to [product] and it's been fantastic. Everything that I needed and nothing that I don't. Smooth, good UI, great instant data. We both save $10 if you use my refer-a-friend link: [referral link]
0 to 2

Why it backfires: Identical text is the easiest thing for a filter, a moderator or a bored reader to spot.

Write this instead: write each reply for the thread it is in.

Reddit user
r/startups
u/JustTryingTo_Align
Founders doing their own sales, How much time on cold emails? - I will not promote
u/erickrealz
•
Better example, real comment
30 minutes per email is insane and completely unsustainable. You're over-researching and over-personalizing. The return on that extra 20 minutes of research is basically zero compared to a 5 minute email that hits the main pain point. Batch your work. Spend one hour building a list of 50 leads in Apollo or LinkedIn Sales Navigator. Spend another hour writing 3 to 4 email templates for different personas...

Reddit lists mass-posting the same content as spam.

18. Bashing a competitor to recommend yourself

The comment in item 17 does this too. It opens “GA4 is unusable.” In this case they can get away with it because they’re bashing a big corporation, but I recommend avoiding this with smaller, direct competitors.

Why it backfires: It makes you look insecure, and the competitor’s users come to defend it.

Write this instead: say what you do differently and who the competitor suits better.

19. Your brand in every comment

Your brand in every comment you write, or an account that only shows up when the brand is mentioned.

Why it backfires: Your history turns into a list of ads. Moderators can also filter a brand name so every future mention goes to their queue.

Sagar Panchal
•
The Biggest Lie in Reddit Marketing? A Reddit moderator can shut down your entire brand promotion campaign in minutes. Stop Saying You Can Post in Any Subreddit. "We can promote your brand in any subreddit." No, you can't. As someone who also moderates Reddit communities, I can tell you what most marketers never mention. Moderators decide what stays. Moderators decide what gets removed. Moderators decide who gets banned. And moderators have far more tools than most people realize. If a brand suddenly appears in dozens of comments overnight, it doesn't look like organic discussion. It looks coordinated. That's when moderators start investigating. They can: ✅ Remove your comments ✅ Remove your posts ✅ Filter your brand name ✅ Send every future mention to the moderation queue ✅ Ban the accounts involved Once your brand gets flagged, even genuine discussions can struggle to appear. This is why Reddit marketing isn't about finding hundreds of accounts. It's about understanding communities before mentioning a brand. The best Reddit campaigns don't force conversations. They become part of conversations that were already happening. Because on Reddit... You don't control the community. The moderators do. And if your strategy ignores moderators, you don't have a Reddit strategy. You have a countdown to getting removed.
187 comments · 1 reposts
Read on LinkedIn

Do this instead: most of your comments shouldn’t mention the business at all.

20. The link edited in later

A helpful comment that gets upvoted, then edited to add your link.

Why it backfires: People notice edits, and the upvotes were given to a different comment.

Do this instead: leave it alone. If someone asks for the link, reply to them.

DMs, discount codes and hidden links

21. “DM me for the link”

Using private messages to get round a no-links rule, or “reply YES and I’ll send it”.

Reddit user
r/automation
u/spacenyxy
How do you find clients to sell ai agents to?
Reddit user
u/plain_bagel_99 •
Real comment
Oh I see cant post links in this sub, sounds good I'll link it or you just google it, but I suggest waiting 48 hours for our V2 to launch, should be a game changer ... Name is [product], I'll dm you the link
1

Why it backfires: It hides the answer from everyone else reading the thread, and it looks like a way round the subreddit’s rules.

Write this instead: put the answer in the thread.

Ross Simmonds lists mass DMs among the fast tracks to a ban.

22. Discount codes and votes for rewards

A discount code dropped into a thread that didn’t ask for one, or a reward for anyone who upvotes.

Why it backfires: A code nobody asked for is an ad. Offering something in return for upvotes is buying votes, which Reddit treats as vote manipulation.

Do this instead: offer a code only where the subreddit’s rules allow offers.

23. Hidden referral links

A shortened or referral link presented as “a resource that helped me”.

Why it backfires: When someone spots the tracking code, “a resource that helped me” becomes “I get paid for this”.

Write this instead: the full link, and a line saying you earn from it.

Free download

Get the 45 rules as an .md file for Claude or ChatGPT

The Reddit Rulebook checks a draft the way this page does, and goes further than the checker.

Checks the subreddit's own rules first
Names the rule and quotes the line that breaks it
Rewrites the draft so it would pass
Works inClaudeChatGPT

We'll email you the .md file.

For Claude and ChatGPT
The Reddit Rulebook
45 mistakes that get marketers removed or banned, and the fix for each
Sensorhub

AI-written and corporate-sounding posts

24. Reddit AI comments and posts

Tidy paragraphs, a summary line, no opinion. The reply here got more upvotes than the post.

Reddit user
r/ValueInvesting • 8 Nov 2026
u/quiet_harbor_42
Real post
Semiconductor stocks screen cheapest at the top…
We run a small equity research shop, [firm], and just published a memo testing a claim our coverage keeps running into. In semiconductors, the fundamentals always look best at the top. They look cheap, but they are not. The mechanism is arithmetic, not sentiment... The targets stand because the models stand. The rating changed because our confidence in the denominator does not. Full memo with the four-cycle historical record and sourcing: [link to their own site]
61106
u/mwani13
u/mwani13 • 8 Nov 2026
Post is AI generated..

Why it backfires: Readers call it out and stop reading, and many subreddits ban it. Reddit’s CEO told moderators that unlabeled AI accounts are banned without warning.

Writing with AI is not against Reddit’s sitewide rules. Each community sets its own, and the big ones are the strictest. By late 2024, 17% of the largest subreddits had a rule about AI, against 1.2% of all subreddits, a 2025 study found.

Write this instead: write it yourself and keep it short. Don’t run a draft through a humanizer. The example below has no link and no product in it at all.

u/Heavy_Discussion3518
r/ValueInvesting • 24 Jan 2026
Better example, real post
Why Adobe, Salesforce, and SaaS in general are just beginning their decline
First off, why should you even listen? Two reasons: I'm a SWE with 20+ years of experience that has worked across embedded, mobile, and scaled backend systems including a tenure as Sr Staff at a FAANG adjacent company in SF. Second reason - this is written by hand with no AI assistance. … But the writing is on the wall. In general, the decline of SaaS has just begun, and value is shifting to physical assets, where differentiation in quality can't be automated away.
u/RogerThatRacing
u/RogerThatRacing • 24 Jan 2026
I was pleased that this was no AI slop

25. The signature or newsletter plug

Reddit user
r/SaaS • 25 Sep 2023
u/northfield_design
Real post
How to get your first 1,000 users in 100 days & your first $10k
Now that you have your landing page set up, your value propositions defined, and you've identified a pressing problem to solve using a bunch of tools, it's time for the real thing to happen... Ps: If you liked this, you'll enjoy my newsletter -> ([their Substack link]) where I break down ideas on how to grow your SaaS PPS: If you want someone to help with your SaaS growth, I'm happy to optimize your copy + your onboarding flow + help you with overall growth strategies- Just DM me :)
146
u/ghad0265
u/ghad0265 • 25 Sep 2023
Newsletter spam again.

Why it backfires: It turns a useful post into a funnel at the very end, which is usually the part people reply to.

Write this instead: no signature. Your username is the signature. The example below has nothing to sell in the post. Its author mentioned a paid academy only in replies to people who thanked them.

u/laddermanUS
r/AI_Agents • 9 Feb 2025
Better example, real post
My guide on what tools to use to build AI agents (if you are a newb)
First off let's remember that everyone was a newb once, I love newbs and if your are one in the Ai agent space...... Welcome, we salute you. In this simple guide im going to cut through all the hype and BS and get straight to the point. … And my last bit of advice for all newbs to Agentic Ai. Its not magic, this agent stuff, I know it can seem like it. Try and think of agents quite simply as a few lines of code hosted on the internet that uses an LLM and can plugin to other tools. Over thinking them actually makes it harder to design and deploy them.
The author, replying to a thank-you
The author, replying to a thank-you • 3 points
You are most welcome. If you want to learn everything there is to know then feel free to check out my AI Academy, where I teach everything you need to know to get started and give way all my AI Agent templates. [link to a paid community]

26. Buzzwords and heavy formatting

Buzzwords, bold headings and emoji bullets in a comment.

Why it backfires: They say nothing, and they sound like a company wrote the comment.

Write this instead: plain sentences, the way you’d say it to a colleague.

27. Asking for feedback, then arguing

Why it backfires: People stop giving feedback, and the thread becomes about your tone.

Do this instead: thank them and ask one follow-up question.

New accounts, karma limits and unread rules

28. Posting without reading the rules

Some subreddits ban any mention of a brand.

Why it backfires: Rules differ from one subreddit to the next, and moderators have little patience for a post that breaks one in its title.

Do this instead: read the rules and the pinned posts before the first comment.

29. Promotion from a brand-new account

A promotional first post from an account that is a few hours old.

Why it backfires: Reddit’s filters hold posts from new accounts with little karma. Its CEO told moderators that 30% of posts from new accounts are removed.

Do this instead: warm the account up first. Chapter 2 covers Reddit’s karma requirements and new account restrictions.

30. An ad dressed as something else

A survey, a “we’re hiring” post, an AMA that answers every question with the product.

Why it backfires: People came for a survey, a job or an answer. When they get an ad, they feel tricked.

Do this instead: post a survey, a job ad or an AMA only when it is one. If you run a survey, share the results in the same subreddit.

Habits that get an account flagged

31. Posting too often in one subreddit

Three posts in a day, or a comment under every new thread.

Why it backfires: The same name on every thread wears people out, even when each post is fine on its own.

Do this instead: two or three posts a week in one subreddit is fine, and you can ramp up once you’re a regular there. Comment only where you have something to add.

32. Replying to every comment in a thread

Answering each person in a “best tools” thread with your product.

Why it backfires: It turns someone else’s thread into your sales floor.

Do this instead: one reply, to the person who asked.

33. Turning up within minutes of every mention

The brand account appears under every mention of the brand, every time, within minutes.

Why it backfires: It shows you are tracking the keyword, and people feel watched.

Do this instead: answer the mentions that carry a real question. Leave the rest to other users unless you can fix something.

34. Deleting a downvoted comment and posting it again

Why it backfires: Your history shows the gaps, and the second attempt has the same problem as the first.

Do this instead: leave it up, read why it was downvoted, and write the next one differently.

35. Farming karma, then switching to promotion

Weeks of memes and one-line jokes, then a product post.

Why it backfires: The history doesn’t match the product, and people check. “Nice karma farm” is a common reply.

Do this instead: build your history in the subreddits where your buyers are, on the topics you’ll talk about later. I cover it in Chapter 2.

36. Posting in a subreddit you haven’t joined

Why it backfires: In our experience, many subreddits hide comments from people who haven’t joined, and nothing tells you. You see the comment and nobody else does.

Do this instead: join first, then post.

37. The same post in many subreddits at once

Why it backfires: Reddit lists repeated content as spam, and each subreddit can see the others in your history.

Do this instead: write it for one community. If it does well, adapt it for the next one a few days later.

38. A burst of brand mentions

Ten honest mentions in one afternoon.

Why it backfires: Moderators read a sudden burst as coordinated, as one of them explains, even when every comment is genuine.

Do this instead: spread the mentions over weeks.

Shortcuts that backfire

39. Running a scheduler or a script on the account

Why it backfires: Reddit now labels permitted automated accounts and can ask an account that behaves like one to prove a person is behind it, TechCrunch reports.

Do this instead: post by hand.

40. AI-written text where the subreddit bans it

Item 24 is about how it reads. This one is about the rule.

Why it backfires: It breaks a written rule, which is the simplest reason a moderator can have to remove you.

Do this instead: read the subreddit’s rule on AI before you post, and write it yourself.

41. Buying an aged account

An old account with karma, bought to skip the warm-up.

Why it backfires: Its history has nothing to do with what you now post, and people read histories. Reddit doesn’t say how it treats sold accounts.

Do this instead: warm up your own. The plan is in Chapter 2.

42. A case study that brags about seeding Reddit

Why it backfires: The case study becomes the evidence. A game marketing agency published write-ups about seeding Reddit with posts from fake players, then took them down when redditors found them, PC Gamer reported.

Do this instead: if you wouldn’t publish how you did it, don’t do it.

43. Staff or customers recommending you without saying who they are

Why it backfires: It is the fake testimonial with real people in it. Outside Reddit it is also a legal risk: the US FTC rule on fake reviews covers insider reviews that don’t clearly disclose the connection.

Do this instead: they can post, with one line saying who they are.

44. Claims with no source

“Studies show we’re ten times faster”, with no study.

Why it backfires: Someone will ask for the study, and having none is worse than never making the claim.

Write this instead: link the source, or give your own numbers and say how you got them.

45. Hijacking the top comment

Replying to the top comment with something unrelated, so more people see it.

Why it backfires: It is off-topic on purpose, and the first people to see it are the ones who liked the comment you interrupted.

Do this instead: reply where your answer belongs, even if fewer people see it there.

Saying who you are, done well

The list can read as “never mention your product”. That’s wrong. These comments named the author’s own product and were upvoted.

Reddit user
r/dataengineering
u/QuiteOK123
[product] vs AWS self made
u/WhipsAndMarkovChains
•
Good example, real comment
Full disclosure: I work at [product]. One of the benefits of [product] is that your engineers don't have to do the work of stitching all of those AWS services together. This is especially relevant for you since you're such a small team.
21
Reddit user
r/devops
u/guigouz
Open source observability - what is your take?
u/the_ml_guy
•
Good example, real comment
Hi there! [product] founder here. I am actually really surprised to see you mention [product] as resource-hungry and wanted to chime in. ... I'm curious what kind of setup or volume gave you that impression?
21
u/CxPlanner
u/CxPlanner • 3 Jan 2026
Agree with @the_ml_guy - [product] is really nice and light! Only on large queries across big data sets - so not daily stuff.
Reddit user
r/macapps
u/thehappydoor
AI-powered "second brain" app for macOS (offline-first, optional tagging)
u/ewqeqweqweqweqweqw
•
Good example, real comment
Hello, [name] co-founder of [product] here. Thank you for the mention. There is no silver bullet for what OP is looking for, but leveraging [another product] with a native AI assistant seems to me the best solution.
11
u/300000BCE
u/300000BCE • 28 Jan 2026
Lifetime user and happy to be one

All three have the same things in common. The thread was already about the product or asked for tools, the role came in the first line, and the answer fitted the question.

Where disclosure still fails

This comment opened with “Disclosure” and was still downvoted and called out. The thread asked what to learn first, and the reply dropped a product link without answering that.

Reddit user
r/gis
u/pavellikesminecraft
New to GIS | what should I learn and build first?
Reddit user
u/support_stack_ai •
Real comment
Disclosure: I work at [product]. You could try [product link] — it's browser-based, easy to get started with, and has a fairly generous free tier.
-5
u/rsclay
u/rsclay • 14 Jan 2026
shilling your product in the comments without disclosure that it's yours is generally frowned upon on reddit btw! you've been doing it a lot lately.

When nobody mentions your brand, let your profile do it

Most threads never ask for a product like yours, and mentioning it anyway is the mistake the list above describes. So don’t force it. Put who you are and what you build in your profile, and spend your time being useful in the thread.

People who liked your answer will click your name. Your profile says what you build, and they look it up themselves. You never had to bring it up in the thread.

If you are confident you gave someone real value, and they replied or thanked you, you can send one short, casual DM. No link and no offer, just a line saying you’re happy to help if they need more. One message, to one person, once. If they don’t answer, leave it.

This is not item 21. There the answer is hidden in a private message. Here the answer was already in the thread, and the message asks for nothing. Some people still dislike unsolicited DMs, so skip it when the thread was a one-off exchange.

What gets you banned on Reddit

Most of the mistakes above only lose you that one post. Some can get you banned from a subreddit, or from Reddit as a whole.

A subreddit ban comes from moderators, usually after a second offence or one dishonest one: the fake question, “not affiliated”, an edited-in link. Being banned from a subreddit doesn’t touch the rest of Reddit.

A Reddit ban comes from Reddit’s admins, and the items that lead there are 11, 12, 13, 17 and 37: several accounts working together, bought or organised votes, a new account to get round a ban, and the same content posted in bulk. Reddit’s help page says spam can lead to a temporary or a permanent ban.

Reddit bans at scale. In the first half of 2025 it banned 2,613,473 users, temporarily or for good, TorrentFreak reports from Reddit’s transparency report.

People also search for a “Reddit IP ban”. Reddit doesn’t publish how it links accounts to each other. What it does say is that using another account to get round a ban is Reddit ban evasion, and that moderators can switch on a filter that looks for it. Assume Reddit can link any account you open after a ban to the banned one.

One r/salestechniques moderator published a list of more than 200 companies whose names are auto-removed and whose accounts are permanently banned there. A banned account is replaceable. A banned brand name isn’t.

It happens to well-funded companies too. Moderators of r/humanresources pinned a warning to “be careful of Rippling bots”, and a moderator’s post in r/smallbusiness naming Rippling and Wishpond got 610 upvotes, Foundation reports. Moderators wrote those warnings. Reddit didn’t ban either company, and the article carries no reply from either one. The cost is a pinned post that outranks you in that community.

How to get unbanned from Reddit

From a subreddit: message the moderators once, from the banned account. Say what you did, that you’ve read the rules, and that it won’t happen again. Don’t argue.

From Reddit: if your Reddit account was suspended, use the appeal form at reddit.com/appeals, again from the banned account, and keep it to two sentences.

Chapter 7 has the full version, including how to tell a ban from a shadowban.

How to promote on Reddit without getting removed

Flip the list around and it comes down to five habits. Chapter 4 shows what to write once you have them.

  1. Join the subreddit and read its rules before the first comment.

  2. Write there for two weeks before the business comes up.

  3. Answer the question in the thread itself. No link unless someone asks.

  4. Say who you are every time the product comes up.

  5. One account per person, and the accounts never vote on or reply to each other.

Check your draft before you post

Two ways to test a draft against this list. Use the checker, or paste the prompt into Claude or ChatGPT.

Check your draft15 checks

Paste a comment or a post. It is checked against the mistakes on this page, here in your browser.

0 words
CheckResultWhat we found and what to change
No link
No tracked link
Answer stays in the thread
No hidden affiliation
Says who you are
Doesn't open with the product
No sales language
No discount or vote ask
No signature or newsletter
No competitor bashing
No buzzwords
Plain formatting
No shouting
No AI-sounding phrases
Short enough for a comment
Nothing you paste leaves your browser. Paste at least a sentence to see the result.

Or use this prompt

Paste your draft into Claude or ChatGPT with this prompt.

Open in Claude
I'm about to post this on Reddit in r/[subreddit]. Here are that subreddit's rules: [paste the rules]. Here is my draft: [paste the draft]. Check it against these: it reads as an ad, it hides who I am, it has a link nobody asked for, it sounds written by AI or by a marketing team, it breaks one of the subreddit's rules. For each one, say pass or fail and quote the sentence that fails. Then rewrite the draft so it would pass, in plain words, under 80 words if it is a comment. Don't add a link or a product name that wasn't in my draft.
Free download

Get the 45 rules as an .md file for Claude or ChatGPT

The Reddit Rulebook checks a draft the way this page does, and goes further than the checker.

Checks the subreddit's own rules first
Names the rule and quotes the line that breaks it
Rewrites the draft so it would pass
Works inClaudeChatGPT

We'll email you the .md file.

For Claude and ChatGPT
The Reddit Rulebook
45 mistakes that get marketers removed or banned, and the fix for each
Sensorhub

Sensorhub finds the threads for you and stops there. We never automate posting, astroturfing, or use fake accounts or fake upvotes. Yes, it’s harder, and it takes more time, but it is the right way to use the platform. Everything else is simply black-hat or straight-up illegal.

Common questions about removed Reddit posts

What does “removed by Reddit's filters” mean?

It means Reddit's own automated system took the post down, and the subreddit's moderators didn't. Reddit says its spam filter can stop posts from new accounts with little karma. If you think it got yours wrong, send the subreddit's moderators one short message and ask them to approve it.

How can you tell if a moderator or a filter removed your post?

Timing is the quickest sign. A post that disappears within seconds was caught by a filter, and one that disappears hours later, with a note, was removed by a person.

Does Reddit tell you when your post is removed?

Often it doesn't. In a 2019 study of 907 Reddit users, 41.8% hadn't noticed their post was gone until the researchers told them. Open your post in a private window to check that other people can see it.

What is the Reddit 9:1 rule?

It's a guideline some communities use: no more than 10% of what you post should be your own. It isn't a sitewide Reddit rule, and Reddit itself has no rule against promoting your business. In this guide I use a looser ratio of three to five helpful comments for each one that mentions the business.

Is AI-written content allowed on Reddit?

Reddit's sitewide rules don't ban writing with AI, but each community sets its own rule and the big ones are the strictest. By late 2024, 17% of the largest subreddits had a rule about AI. Readers also call it out and stop reading, so I'd write it yourself.

Can you make a new account after a Reddit ban?

You shouldn't, because Reddit calls that ban evasion, and it puts the new account and any other account you run at risk. Appeal from the banned account.

Do this this week

Chapter 6 checklist
0 of 5 done
1Look at what you've already posted20 minutes
2Before your next post10 minutes
Your ticks are saved in this browser, so you can come back to it.

Social listening and AI visibility platform for marketers

Grow your presence across AI search, social, and the web

Grow your presence across AI search, social, and the web

Grow your presence across AI search, social, and the web

Off-site visibility insights, every month

© 2026 Iterato Ltd. All rights reserved.

Off-site visibility insights, every month

© 2026 Iterato Ltd. All rights reserved.

Off-site visibility insights, every month

© 2026 Iterato Ltd. All rights reserved.